Skip to content

For independent restaurant and cafe owners

Restaurant Menu Engineering Calculator: Food Cost and Margin Matrix

Portion costs in, Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles and Dogs out.

Your dishes

DishPlate costMenu priceNumber soldFood costMarginClassRemove
29.3%$9.90Plowhorse
37.3%$9.40Plowhorse
42.6%$19.50Puzzle
24.4%$6.80Dog
21.3%$12.60Puzzle
5 of 10 free dishes used

Overall food cost

31.9%

Total margin

$7,244

Avg margin per dish sold

$10.50

The profit line

Popularity line

14.0%

Share of items sold

StarsPopular, high margin

Popular and profitable. Keep the recipe and portion consistent, give it the best spot on the menu, and test a small price rise.

None

PlowhorsesPopular, low margin

Popular but thin margin. Trim the plate cost, pair it with a high-margin side, or raise the price in small steps.

  • Cheeseburger$9.90 margin, 44.9% of sales
  • Fish tacos$9.40 margin, 26.1% of sales

PuzzlesSlow, high margin

Profitable but slow. Rename it, describe it better, move it to a prime spot, or have servers recommend it.

  • Ribeye$19.50 margin, 6.5% of sales
  • Pasta primavera$12.60 margin, 13.8% of sales

DogsSlow, low margin

Neither popular nor profitable. Remove it, rework it, or raise the price so the few who order it are worth serving.

  • House salad$6.80 margin, 8.7% of sales

Download the matrix as a PDF report or a spreadsheet

Everything on screen stays free. Unlock this tool once, or get all ten with All-Access.

Saved menus

Save your work and reopen it on any device

Everything on screen stays free. Unlock this tool once, or get all ten with All-Access.

What it does

  • Food cost percentage and contribution margin for every dish.
  • The classic menu-engineering matrix: Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles and Dogs, with what to do about each.
  • Keep an ingredient price book so one supplier price change updates every dish.

Questions

What do I need to get started?

For each dish: what it costs to make, what you charge, and roughly how many you sell in a period. The matrix appears as soon as you have a few dishes in.

How are Stars and Dogs decided?

Each dish is compared with your menu’s average popularity and average margin, the standard menu-engineering method. The thresholds are shown on screen.

More tools

Restaurant Menu Engineering Calculator: Food Cost and Margin Matrix | NorthKeep Suite